GolfUpdated 8 min readBy zensportsy
What Are Bullseye Putters Worth? – ZenSportsy guide cover

Quick answer: Most Bullseye putters are worth a modest amount, but values range widely. Common, well-used Bulls Eye putters from Acushnet and Titleist sit in the lower value tier, while clean examples, early or unusual versions, special markings, original grips and headcovers, and collectible Scotty Cameron Bullseye models can be worth considerably more. Condition, era, maker, markings, shaft and originality matter most. The Bulls Eye was designed by John Reuter Jr., and Acushnet began advertising it in January 1957. To value yours, identify the version, assess condition and compare recent completed sales of the same model. If you want a putter to play rather than collect, see our guide to the best rated golf putters.

The Bullseye (often written Bulls Eye) is one of the most famous putter designs in golf history. Its simple, center-shafted brass head has been used by generations of golfers and remains a popular collectible. Because so many were made over so many years, values vary enormously. This guide explains how to identify your Bullseye, what drives value and how to estimate what yours might be worth. For background on putter styles, see the different types of putters.

Bullseye Putter Value at a Glance

FactorLower valueHigher value
ConditionHeavy wear, dents, rust, replaced partsClean, original, minimal wear
Era and versionCommon later productionEarly, rare or unusual versions
MarkingsCommon stampsSpecial stamps, prototypes or tour markings
OriginalityReplaced grip or shaftOriginal grip, shaft and headcover
MakerMass-produced versionsCollectible versions such as Scotty Cameron Bullseyes
DocumentationNoneProvenance, receipts or history

We describe value in tiers rather than exact figures because prices depend heavily on condition and demand, and they change over time. Always compare recent completed sales of the same version.

A Brief History of the Bullseye Putter

The Bulls Eye putter was designed by John Reuter Jr. and became one of the most successful putter designs ever made. Acushnet, the parent company of Titleist, began advertising the Bulls Eye in January 1957, and production expanded under its ownership. The design features a center-shafted head, traditionally made of brass, with a simple flange shape that many golfers find easy to aim. Over the decades, many versions were produced with different materials, shafts, grips and markings.

Later, Scotty Cameron produced his own Bullseye-inspired putters as part of his work with Titleist, adding a distinct and highly collectible branch to the Bullseye family. For more on that relationship, see who makes Scotty Cameron putters.

How to Identify Your Bullseye Putter

  1. Check the stamping. Look for “Bulls Eye”, “Acushnet”, “Titleist” or “Scotty Cameron” markings and any model names.
  2. Examine the head material. Classic versions use brass; others may use different metals or finishes.
  3. Look at the shaft. Note whether it is a flanged or straight-blade shape and its shaft style and material.
  4. Inspect the grip. Original grips can add value to collectible versions.
  5. Note special marks. Prototype, tour or limited markings can significantly increase value.
Version typeTypical featuresGeneral value tier
Common Acushnet/Titleist Bulls EyeBrass head, standard stamping, used conditionLower
Clean older Bulls EyeGood condition, original partsLow to moderate
Unusual or early variantsRare stampings or featuresModerate to higher
Scotty Cameron Bullseye modelsCameron branding and millingHigher; collectible
Tour, prototype or limited modelsSpecial markings and provenanceHighest; collector market

What Affects a Bullseye Putter’s Value?

Condition

Condition is the single biggest factor. Brass is relatively soft and easily dinged, so putters with few marks, a clean face and no heavy wear are more valuable. Over-polishing or refinishing can reduce collector value.

Originality

Collectors prefer original shafts, grips and headcovers. A replaced grip may make the putter more playable, but it often lowers collector value.

Rarity and markings

Rare versions, short production runs, special stampings and tour-issued putters attract more interest. Even small differences in markings can separate a common putter from a sought-after one.

Maker and brand

Scotty Cameron Bullseye models are among the most collectible, because they combine a classic design with one of the most valued names in putters.

Demand

Collector demand rises and falls. Interest in vintage golf equipment and particular models can change values over time.

How to Estimate Your Bullseye’s Value

  1. Identify the exact version using stampings, materials and features.
  2. Grade the condition honestly: excellent, good, fair or poor.
  3. Search completed sales, not asking prices, for the same version and condition.
  4. Factor in originality: original grip, shaft and headcover add value.
  5. Consider an expert opinion for rare or tour models, such as a golf collectibles specialist.

Where to Sell a Bullseye Putter

Common Bullseye putters can be sold through online marketplaces, golf trade-in programs or local golf shops. Rare or collectible models may achieve better prices through specialist collector forums or golf memorabilia auctions. Clear photos of the stamping, face, sole, shaft and grip help buyers judge condition. For general selling tips, see where to sell golf clubs.

Selling optionBest forProsCons
Online marketplaceCommon and mid-value puttersLarge audienceFees and shipping
Trade-in programQuick saleConvenientLower value
Local golf shopCommon puttersEasyLimited demand
Collector forum or auctionRare and collectible modelsKnowledgeable buyersSlower process

Are Bullseye Putters Still Good to Play?

Yes. Many golfers still use Bullseye putters because of their simple look and center-shafted design, which places the shaft over the sweet spot. They suit golfers who like a compact, traditional head and a pendulum-style stroke. If you want a modern equivalent, see the best center-shafted putters.

FeatureBullseyeModern mallet
Head sizeCompactLarger
ForgivenessLowerHigher
Alignment aidsMinimalOften extensive
FeelTraditional brass feelVaries; often insert or milled
Shaft positionCenter-shaftedVarious

For a comparison of head styles, read are mallet putters better.

Caring for a Bullseye Putter

Brass can tarnish and dent, so keep the putter in a headcover and store it somewhere dry. If you plan to sell it as a collectible, avoid aggressive polishing or refinishing, which can reduce value. For playing putters, a gentle clean is fine; see how to clean golf clubs. If you want to replace a worn grip on a playing putter, see how to regrip golf clubs.

Spotting Fakes and Misidentified Putters

Our general guide to checking used golf clubs before buying can help you assess condition.

Should You Collect or Play Your Bullseye?

If your Bullseye is a common model in used condition, its playing value may outweigh its collector value, so enjoy using it. If it is clean, rare or a Scotty Cameron model, consider keeping it as a collectible and buying a separate putter for regular play. Modern putters offer more forgiveness and fitting options; see the best putters for beginners and how much putters cost.

Why the Bullseye Design Has Lasted

The Bullseye’s longevity comes from its simplicity. A compact head, center-shafted design and clean lines make it easy to set up square and stroke smoothly. Many golfers also like the soft feel of brass and the nostalgia of playing a classic design. Those qualities explain why the Bullseye remains popular decades after it first appeared.

Common Mistakes When Valuing a Bullseye

Bullseye Putters and Modern Fitting

If you want to play a Bullseye regularly, consider having the length and lie checked. Vintage putters may not match modern standard lengths, and a putter that is too long or too short can affect your posture and aim. See what length golf clubs you need and how to get fitted for golf clubs.

Condition Grading Guide

GradeWhat it looks likeEffect on value
ExcellentMinimal marks, clean face, original grip and finishHighest for that version
Very goodLight marks from careful use, original partsStrong
GoodVisible wear and dings but structurally soundModerate
FairHeavy wear, tarnish, possibly replaced gripLower
PoorDeep dents, bent shaft, rust or major repairsLowest; often bought as a player or for parts

Be honest when grading. Buyers will compare your photos closely, and accurate descriptions build trust and lead to smoother sales. Photograph the putter in good natural light from several angles, including close-ups of the stamping, face and sole.

Photographing a Bullseye for Sale

Bullseye Putters as Gifts and Heirlooms

Because the Bullseye has been around for so long, many golfers inherit one from a parent or grandparent. In those cases, sentimental value can far outweigh market value. If you plan to keep an inherited putter, store it in a dry place with a headcover, avoid refinishing it and consider a simple display mount. If you want to use it on the course, a fresh grip can make it more comfortable without changing the head; see the best golf club grips.

Questions to Ask Before Buying a Bullseye

Brass vs. Other Head Materials

Traditional Bullseye putters use brass, which gives a soft, muted feel but dents and tarnishes more easily than stainless steel. Some later and modern Bullseye-style putters use other metals or finishes for durability. For playing purposes, the material mainly affects feel and appearance; for collectors, originality of the material and finish is usually more important than which metal was used. If you are choosing a Bullseye to play rather than collect, pick the version whose feel and weight you like best on the practice green. A short test session tells you more than any description.

Key Takeaways

Bottom Line

What a Bullseye putter is worth depends on its version, condition, originality and rarity. Common, used examples have modest value and still make enjoyable playing putters, while clean, rare or Scotty Cameron Bullseyes can attract strong collector interest. Identify your model, grade its condition honestly and compare recent completed sales. If you are shopping for a putter to play, see our guide to the best rated golf putters.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Bullseye putters worth?

Most common Bullseye putters have modest value, while clean, rare, early or Scotty Cameron Bullseye models can be worth considerably more. Condition and originality matter most.

Who designed the Bullseye putter?

The Bulls Eye putter was designed by John Reuter Jr.

When did Acushnet start selling the Bulls Eye?

Acushnet began advertising the Bulls Eye putter in January 1957.

How can I tell what Bullseye putter I have?

Check the stampings, head material, shaft, grip and any special markings, then compare with known examples.

Are Scotty Cameron Bullseye putters valuable?

They are among the most collectible Bullseye versions because of the Scotty Cameron name and milling.

Should I polish my Bullseye putter before selling?

Avoid heavy polishing or refinishing, as it can reduce collector value.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *